Choose the Right Test Head – Flex PCB (2024)

Introduction to Test Heads

When configuring an automated test equipment (ATE) system to test electronic devices, one of the most critical components to select is the test head. The test head is the interface between the ATE and the device under test (DUT). It houses the pin electronics that generate test signals and measure responses from the DUT. Choosing the right test head is essential for ensuring your ATE system can test devices thoroughly, accurately, and reliably.

There are several key factors to consider when selecting a test head:

• Number of pins/channels
• Supported signaling standards and voltage/current ranges
• Switching topology and architecture
• Modularity and configurability
• Reliability and serviceability
• Cost

Carefully evaluating your testing requirements and comparing them against the specifications and features of available test heads will help you make the optimal choice for your ATE setup. Let’s examine each of these factors in more detail.

Test Head Pin Count and Channel Density

One of the primary specifications of a test head is the number of pins or channels it supports. This determines how many signals the test head can send to and receive from the DUT simultaneously. Higher pin counts enable more comprehensive and parallel testing, which can significantly reduce test times. However, higher density test heads also tend to be more complex and expensive.

Test head pin counts can range from less than 100 to over 10,000 pins. The right pin count depends on the complexity of the devices you need to test:

In addition to the total number of pins, the density or pins per square inch is an important consideration, especially if you have limited test head space. Higher density allows fitting more pins in a smaller footprint.

Signaling Standards and Voltage/Current Ranges

Test heads need to support the various types of signals required to stimulate the DUT and measure its responses. This includes digital, analog, RF, power, and other specialized signals. Ensure that the test head you choose supports all the signaling standards used by your target devices.

Common digital signaling standards include:

• CMOS
• TTL
• LVDS
• SerDes
• DDR

For analog signals, consider the voltage and current ranges, precision, and bandwidth the test head supports. Some test heads offer extended ranges and software-configurable parameters for flexibility.

Test Head Switching Topology

The switching topology of a test head determines how signals are routed between the ATE pin electronics and the DUT pins. The two main types of switching are:

1. Relay Switching – Uses electromechanical relays to make and break connections. Benefits include low contact resistance, high isolation, and flexibility. Drawbacks include limited switching speed and finite lifetime.

2. Solid-State Switching – Uses semiconductor switches like MOSFETs. Advantages are very high switching speeds and unlimited lifetime. Disadvantages can include higher “on” resistance and lower isolation.

Some test heads use hybrid approaches combining both relays and solid-state switches to optimize performance.

Choose the switching topology that provides sufficient performance for your target devices while considering long-term maintenance costs.

Modularity and Configurability

Test heads with modular and configurable designs provide the flexibility to adapt the ATE system to changing test needs. Modular test heads allow you to swap out different types of pin electronics cards to support various signaling standards and capabilities. This can help future-proof your investment and allow gradually scaling up capabilities as needed.

Some key aspects of modularity and configuration to look for include:

• Swappable pin electronics cards
• Configurable pin grouping and channel granularity
• Programmable signal terminations and load boards
• Compatible with different manipulators and docking interfaces

Highly modular and configurable test heads may have a higher upfront cost but can provide a lower total cost of ownership in the long run by adapting to evolving test needs.

Reliability and Serviceability

Test heads are put under significant stress during usage in an ATE system. They frequently make and break connections, are subjected to ESD events, and can undergo mechanical strain when docking. Therefore, evaluating the reliability and serviceability of a test head is critical, as unplanned downtime and repairs quickly become costly when testing high volumes of devices.

Important reliability and serviceability factors include:

• Rated mating cycles and MTBF for connectors and relays
• Mechanical robustness of the frame and housing
• Modularity for rapid replacement of failed components
• Diagnostics for quickly identifying faults
• Manufacturer warranty, service, and support

Look for test heads with robust designs, extensive self-testing capabilities, and strong vendor support to maximize system uptime and productivity.

Cost Considerations

Finally, the cost of the test head itself must be considered as part of the overall budget for an ATE system. Test head prices can range from tens of thousands to over a million dollars depending on the pin count, capabilities, and performance level.

The key is to find the best price-to-performance ratio that meets all your technical requirements. Consider both the upfront capital expenditure as well as long-term maintenance and operating costs. Modular test heads, while perhaps more expensive initially, can offer a better value in the long run. Also, consider the cost of any additional training, support, and infrastructure required.

Getting budgetary quotes from multiple test head vendors and calculating the total cost of ownership over the ATE system’s expected lifetime will help make an informed decision.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main types of test head switching?

The two main types of test head switching are relay switching and solid-state switching. Relay switching uses electromechanical relays and provides high isolation and flexibility but has limited speed and lifetime. Solid-state switching uses semiconductor switches and offers high speed and unlimited cycling but has lower isolation and higher “on” resistance.

How do I determine the right pin count for my test head?

The optimal pin count depends on the complexity and parallelism of the devices you need to test. Simple analog devices may only require a few hundred pins, while complex ICs like SoCs and FPGAs can utilize thousands of pins. High-volume production testing can benefit from higher pin counts to enable multi-site testing. Estimate the maximum number of signals you need to test simultaneously, and leave some margin for future needs.

What signaling standards do test heads support?

Test heads can support a wide variety of signaling standards for digital, analog, and RF interfaces. Common standards include CMOS, TTL, LVDS, and SerDes for digital signals. For analog signals, test heads provide configurable ranges for voltage and current measurements. Ensure the test head you choose has the necessary voltage/current ranges, precision, and bandwidth required by your target devices.

How important is modularity in a test head?

Modularity is an important consideration for test heads, especially in environments where test needs may evolve over time. A modular test head with swappable pin electronics cards, configurable pin groupings, and programmable terminations provides the flexibility to adapt to changing requirements. This can help futureproof the ATE system and protect the initial investment. The tradeoff is that highly modular test heads often have higher upfront costs.

What are the key factors for test head reliability?

Test head reliability depends on several key factors. These include the rated mating cycles and mean time between failure (MTBF) for connectors and relays, the robustness of the mechanical design, modularity for easy servicing, and diagnostic capabilities for rapid troubleshooting. Working with a vendor that offers strong warranty, service, and support is also important for maximizing long-term reliability and uptime.

Conclusion

Selecting the right test head is a critical decision when configuring an ATE system. The test head serves as the interface between the tester and the device under test, so its capabilities directly impact the thoroughness, accuracy, and efficiency of the testing process.

When evaluating test heads, carefully consider factors such as the number of pins, signaling standards and voltage/current ranges supported, switching topology, modularity and configurability, reliability and serviceability, and cost. Matching these specifications to your particular testing needs will ensure the test head can meet your performance and budget requirements.

While higher pin counts, advanced features, and modularity tend to increase the cost of a test head, it’s important to analyze the total cost of ownership over the lifetime of the ATE system. A premium test head may have a higher upfront cost but can provide significant savings in the long run through faster test times, flexibility to adapt to future needs, and reduced downtime and maintenance costs.

Consulting with experienced ATE engineers and test head vendors can provide valuable guidance in selecting the optimal test head for your application. They can help analyze your specific requirements, recommend suitable options, and even develop custom solutions if needed.

Ultimately, investing the time and effort to choose the right test head will pay dividends in maximizing the performance, reliability, and longevity of your ATE setup. It will enable you to thoroughly test your target devices and have confidence in the quality of the results, while minimizing costs and